1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
|
{-# LANGUAGE CPP #-}
-- | Implements a selective lambda lifter, running late in the optimisation
-- pipeline.
--
-- If you are interested in the cost model that is employed to decide whether
-- to lift a binding or not, look at "GHC.Stg.Lift.Analysis".
-- "GHC.Stg.Lift.Monad" contains the transformation monad that hides away some
-- plumbing of the transformation.
module GHC.Stg.Lift
(
-- * Late lambda lifting in STG
-- $note
stgLiftLams
)
where
import GHC.Prelude
import GHC.Types.Basic
import GHC.Driver.Session
import GHC.Types.Id
import GHC.Stg.FVs ( annBindingFreeVars )
import GHC.Stg.Lift.Analysis
import GHC.Stg.Lift.Monad
import GHC.Stg.Syntax
import GHC.Utils.Outputable
import GHC.Types.Unique.Supply
import GHC.Utils.Panic
import GHC.Types.Var.Set
import Control.Monad ( when )
import Data.Maybe ( isNothing )
-- Note [Late lambda lifting in STG]
-- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
-- $note
-- See also the <https://gitlab.haskell.org/ghc/ghc/wikis/late-lam-lift wiki page>
-- and #9476.
--
-- The basic idea behind lambda lifting is to turn locally defined functions
-- into top-level functions. Free variables are then passed as additional
-- arguments at *call sites* instead of having a closure allocated for them at
-- *definition site*. Example:
--
-- @
-- let x = ...; y = ... in
-- let f = {x y} \a -> a + x + y in
-- let g = {f x} \b -> f b + x in
-- g 5
-- @
--
-- Lambda lifting @f@ would
--
-- 1. Turn @f@'s free variables into formal parameters
-- 2. Update @f@'s call site within @g@ to @f x y b@
-- 3. Update @g@'s closure: Add @y@ as an additional free variable, while
-- removing @f@, because @f@ no longer allocates and can be floated to
-- top-level.
-- 4. Actually float the binding of @f@ to top-level, eliminating the @let@
-- in the process.
--
-- This results in the following program (with free var annotations):
--
-- @
-- f x y a = a + x + y;
-- let x = ...; y = ... in
-- let g = {x y} \b -> f x y b + x in
-- g 5
-- @
--
-- This optimisation is all about lifting only when it is beneficial to do so.
-- The above seems like a worthwhile lift, judging from heap allocation:
-- We eliminate @f@'s closure, saving to allocate a closure with 2 words, while
-- not changing the size of @g@'s closure.
--
-- You can probably sense that there's some kind of cost model at play here.
-- And you are right! But we also employ a couple of other heuristics for the
-- lifting decision which are outlined in "GHC.Stg.Lift.Analysis#when".
--
-- The transformation is done in "GHC.Stg.Lift", which calls out to
-- 'GHC.Stg.Lift.Analysis.goodToLift' for its lifting decision. It relies on
-- "GHC.Stg.Lift.Monad", which abstracts some subtle STG invariants into a
-- monadic substrate.
--
-- Suffice to say: We trade heap allocation for stack allocation.
-- The additional arguments have to passed on the stack (or in registers,
-- depending on architecture) every time we call the function to save a single
-- heap allocation when entering the let binding. Nofib suggests a mean
-- improvement of about 1% for this pass, so it seems like a worthwhile thing to
-- do. Compile-times went up by 0.6%, so all in all a very modest change.
--
-- For a concrete example, look at @spectral/atom@. There's a call to 'zipWith'
-- that is ultimately compiled to something like this
-- (module desugaring/lowering to actual STG):
--
-- @
-- propagate dt = ...;
-- runExperiment ... =
-- let xs = ... in
-- let ys = ... in
-- let go = {dt go} \xs ys -> case (xs, ys) of
-- ([], []) -> []
-- (x:xs', y:ys') -> propagate dt x y : go xs' ys'
-- in go xs ys
-- @
--
-- This will lambda lift @go@ to top-level, speeding up the resulting program
-- by roughly one percent:
--
-- @
-- propagate dt = ...;
-- go dt xs ys = case (xs, ys) of
-- ([], []) -> []
-- (x:xs', y:ys') -> propagate dt x y : go dt xs' ys'
-- runExperiment ... =
-- let xs = ... in
-- let ys = ... in
-- in go dt xs ys
-- @
-- | Lambda lifts bindings to top-level deemed worth lifting (see 'goodToLift').
--
-- (Mostly) textbook instance of the lambda lifting transformation, selecting
-- which bindings to lambda lift by consulting 'goodToLift'.
stgLiftLams :: DynFlags -> UniqSupply -> [InStgTopBinding] -> [OutStgTopBinding]
stgLiftLams dflags us = runLiftM dflags us . foldr liftTopLvl (pure ())
liftTopLvl :: InStgTopBinding -> LiftM () -> LiftM ()
liftTopLvl (StgTopStringLit bndr lit) rest = withSubstBndr bndr $ \bndr' -> do
addTopStringLit bndr' lit
rest
liftTopLvl (StgTopLifted bind) rest = do
let is_rec = isRec $ fst $ decomposeStgBinding bind
when is_rec startBindingGroup
let bind_w_fvs = annBindingFreeVars bind
withLiftedBind TopLevel (tagSkeletonTopBind bind_w_fvs) NilSk $ \mb_bind' -> do
-- We signal lifting of a binding through returning Nothing.
-- Should never happen for a top-level binding, though, since we are already
-- at top-level.
case mb_bind' of
Nothing -> pprPanic "StgLiftLams" (text "Lifted top-level binding")
Just bind' -> addLiftedBinding bind'
when is_rec endBindingGroup
rest
withLiftedBind
:: TopLevelFlag
-> LlStgBinding
-> Skeleton
-> (Maybe OutStgBinding -> LiftM a)
-> LiftM a
withLiftedBind top_lvl bind scope k
= withLiftedBindPairs top_lvl rec pairs scope (k . fmap (mkStgBinding rec))
where
(rec, pairs) = decomposeStgBinding bind
withLiftedBindPairs
:: TopLevelFlag
-> RecFlag
-> [(BinderInfo, LlStgRhs)]
-> Skeleton
-> (Maybe [(Id, OutStgRhs)] -> LiftM a)
-> LiftM a
withLiftedBindPairs top rec pairs scope k = do
let (infos, rhss) = unzip pairs
let bndrs = map binderInfoBndr infos
expander <- liftedIdsExpander
dflags <- getDynFlags
case goodToLift dflags top rec expander pairs scope of
-- @abs_ids@ is the set of all variables that need to become parameters.
Just abs_ids -> withLiftedBndrs abs_ids bndrs $ \bndrs' -> do
-- Within this block, all binders in @bndrs@ will be noted as lifted, so
-- that the return value of @liftedIdsExpander@ in this context will also
-- expand the bindings in @bndrs@ to their free variables.
-- Now we can recurse into the RHSs and see if we can lift any further
-- bindings. We pass the set of expanded free variables (thus OutIds) on
-- to @liftRhs@ so that it can add them as parameter binders.
when (isRec rec) startBindingGroup
rhss' <- traverse (liftRhs (Just abs_ids)) rhss
let pairs' = zip bndrs' rhss'
addLiftedBinding (mkStgBinding rec pairs')
when (isRec rec) endBindingGroup
k Nothing
Nothing -> withSubstBndrs bndrs $ \bndrs' -> do
-- Don't lift the current binding, but possibly some bindings in their
-- RHSs.
rhss' <- traverse (liftRhs Nothing) rhss
let pairs' = zip bndrs' rhss'
k (Just pairs')
liftRhs
:: Maybe (DIdSet)
-- ^ @Just former_fvs@ <=> this RHS was lifted and we have to add @former_fvs@
-- as lambda binders, discarding all free vars.
-> LlStgRhs
-> LiftM OutStgRhs
liftRhs mb_former_fvs rhs@(StgRhsCon ccs con mn ts args)
= assertPpr (isNothing mb_former_fvs)
(text "Should never lift a constructor"
$$ pprStgRhs panicStgPprOpts rhs) $
StgRhsCon ccs con mn ts <$> traverse liftArgs args
liftRhs Nothing (StgRhsClosure _ ccs upd infos body) =
-- This RHS wasn't lifted.
withSubstBndrs (map binderInfoBndr infos) $ \bndrs' ->
StgRhsClosure noExtFieldSilent ccs upd bndrs' <$> liftExpr body
liftRhs (Just former_fvs) (StgRhsClosure _ ccs upd infos body) =
-- This RHS was lifted. Insert extra binders for @former_fvs@.
withSubstBndrs (map binderInfoBndr infos) $ \bndrs' -> do
let bndrs'' = dVarSetElems former_fvs ++ bndrs'
StgRhsClosure noExtFieldSilent ccs upd bndrs'' <$> liftExpr body
liftArgs :: InStgArg -> LiftM OutStgArg
liftArgs a@(StgLitArg _) = pure a
liftArgs (StgVarArg occ) = do
assertPprM (not <$> isLifted occ) (text "StgArgs should never be lifted" $$ ppr occ)
StgVarArg <$> substOcc occ
liftExpr :: LlStgExpr -> LiftM OutStgExpr
liftExpr (StgLit lit) = pure (StgLit lit)
liftExpr (StgTick t e) = StgTick t <$> liftExpr e
liftExpr (StgApp f args) = do
f' <- substOcc f
args' <- traverse liftArgs args
fvs' <- formerFreeVars f
let top_lvl_args = map StgVarArg fvs' ++ args'
pure (StgApp f' top_lvl_args)
liftExpr (StgConApp con mn args tys) = StgConApp con mn <$> traverse liftArgs args <*> pure tys
liftExpr (StgOpApp op args ty) = StgOpApp op <$> traverse liftArgs args <*> pure ty
liftExpr (StgCase scrut info ty alts) = do
scrut' <- liftExpr scrut
withSubstBndr (binderInfoBndr info) $ \bndr' -> do
alts' <- traverse liftAlt alts
pure (StgCase scrut' bndr' ty alts')
liftExpr (StgLet scope bind body)
= withLiftedBind NotTopLevel bind scope $ \mb_bind' -> do
body' <- liftExpr body
case mb_bind' of
Nothing -> pure body' -- withLiftedBindPairs decided to lift it and already added floats
Just bind' -> pure (StgLet noExtFieldSilent bind' body')
liftExpr (StgLetNoEscape scope bind body)
= withLiftedBind NotTopLevel bind scope $ \mb_bind' -> do
body' <- liftExpr body
case mb_bind' of
Nothing -> pprPanic "stgLiftLams" (text "Should never decide to lift LNEs")
Just bind' -> pure (StgLetNoEscape noExtFieldSilent bind' body')
liftAlt :: LlStgAlt -> LiftM OutStgAlt
liftAlt (con, infos, rhs) = withSubstBndrs (map binderInfoBndr infos) $ \bndrs' ->
(,,) con bndrs' <$> liftExpr rhs
|