Post review fixes

mysql-test/include/show_msg80.inc:
  Post review fixes: improved description
mysql-test/r/mysqltest.result:
  Updated result
mysql-test/t/mysqltest.test:
  one sub testcase added

1 files changed, 51 insertions, 22 deletions

diff --git a/mysql-test/include/show_msg80.inc b/mysql-test/include/show_msg80.inc
index acc2c4301a3..42fb35edbcc 100755
--- a/mysql-test/include/show_msg80.inc
+++ b/mysql-test/include/show_msg80.inc
@@ -16,14 +16,19 @@
 # Attention:
 #   - Please do not write any spaces between $message and the "=", because the
 #     assignment will not work.
-#   - Be careful with single quotes. They must be escaped like "''" or "\'".
+#   - Be careful with single quotes within the value. They must be escaped like
+#     "''" or "\'".
+#   - Do not keep the value between single quotes.
 #
 #
-# Content of "$message" and protocol output depending on the assignement:
-# -----------------------------------------------------------------------
-#   <x>  first char after "$message=", 
+# Content of "$message" and protocol output depending on the assignment:
+# ----------------------------------------------------------------------
+#
+#   I is assumed, that the value is not kept between double quotes.
+#
+#   <x>  first character after "$message=", 
 #        where the content is not (space or tab)
-#   <y*> first chat after beginning of the line,
+#   <y*> first character after beginning of the line,
 #        where the content is not (space or tab)
 #   <z>  last char before ";"
 #    |   beginning or end of line
@@ -31,7 +36,7 @@
 #   script: let $message=   <x><whatever0>|
 #           | <y1><whatever1>| 
 #           |................| 
-#           |  <yn><whatevern><z>;
+#           |      <yn><whatevern><z>;
 #   content: "<x><whatever0><new line><y1><whatever1><new line>
 #             ....<new line><yn><whatevern><z>"
 #   protocol output: |<x><whatever0>|
@@ -40,24 +45,17 @@
 #                    |<yn><whatevern><z>|
 #                    |--- 80 dashes ---|
 #
+# Attention:
+#   <x> and <y*> set to characters like "-$#" which are also used 
+#   to start comments, options and the names of mysqltest variables
+#   lead to syntax errors or mangled messages.
+#
 #
 # Examples of messages:
 # ---------------------
 #
-#   Several lines with indentation variant 1:
-#      script:   |let $message= . Testcase 3.1 :  Ensure that Pi is not an|
-#                |              .                 integer number|
-#                |              .                 Third line;
-#      protocol: |. Testcase 3.1 :  Ensure that Pi is not an|
-#                |.                 integer number|
-#                |.                 Third line|
-#                |------ 80 dashes ----|
-#      Please mention that
-#      - the auxiliary "." preserves the indentation.
-#      - it is easy to write the script lines to get a fine indentation
-#      - the "." is printed
-#
-#   Several lines with indentation variant 2:
+#   Variant1 (ease of use): 
+#      Several lines with indentation kept between double quotes
 #      script:   |let $message= 
 #                |" Testcase 3.1 :  Ensure that Pi is not an|
 #                |                  integer number.|
@@ -69,10 +67,32 @@
 #
 #      Please mention that
 #      - the '"' preserves the indentation.
-#      - it is not so easy to write the script lines to get a fine indentation
+#      - it is easy to write the script lines to get a fine indentation,
+#        if the value starts at the beginning of a new line
 #      - the '"' is printed
+#      - there are the least or no problems with characters like "-#$"
 #
-#   Several lines with lost indentation (negative example)
+#
+#   Variant 2 (grep the messages from the protocol is easy):
+#      Several lines with indentation + auxiliary character (".")
+#              at the (non tab or space) beginning of every message line
+#      script:   |let $message= . Testcase 3.1 :  Ensure that Pi is not an|
+#                |              .                 integer number.|
+#                |              .                 Third line;
+#      protocol: |. Testcase 3.1 :  Ensure that Pi is not an|
+#                |.                 integer number.|
+#                |.                 Third line|
+#                |------ 80 dashes ----|
+#      Please mention that
+#      - the auxiliary character preserves the indentation.
+#      - it is easy to write the script lines to get a fine indentation
+#      - the auxiliary character is printed
+#      - it is recommended to use "." as auxiliary character
+#      - auxiliary characters like "-'$#" cause problems
+#      
+#
+#
+#   Bad variant1: Several lines with lost indentation
 #      script:   |let $message=     Here is message line 1
 #                |    message line 2;
 #      protocol: |Here is message line 1|
@@ -80,6 +100,15 @@
 #                |------ 80 dashes ----|
 #      Please mention, that the leading spaces of the message lines disappeared.
 #
+#   Bad variant2: Several lines leading to a syntax error, because of "-"
+#      script:   |let $message= - This is a message
+#                |   - with a second and
+#                |   - third line;
+#      protocol: | - third line;;
+#                |ERROR 42000: You have an error ... near '- third line'
+#                + several following errors
+#
+#
 
 --disable_query_log
 eval SET @utf8_message = CONVERT('$message' using utf8);