Backport of DNF idempotency fixes to YUM

This should fix most outstanding issues with the yum_package
provide and give roughtly the same syntax options as with
DNF (although DNF supports more syntax than YUM does because
the library support is inherently better)

Signed-off-by: Lamont Granquist <lamont@scriptkiddie.org>

3 files changed, 799 insertions, 150 deletions

diff --git a/lib/chef/provider/package/yum.rb b/lib/chef/provider/package/yum.rb
index 121083ea46..07ed56aaf1 100644
--- a/lib/chef/provider/package/yum.rb
+++ b/lib/chef/provider/package/yum.rb
@@ -36,6 +36,7 @@ class Chef
         allow_nils
         use_multipackage_api
         use_package_name_for_source
+        use_magic_version
 
         provides :package, platform_family: "fedora_derived"
 
@@ -64,6 +65,16 @@ class Chef
           current_resource
         end
 
+        def load_after_resource
+          # force the installed version array to repopulate
+          @current_version = []
+          @after_resource = Chef::Resource::YumPackage.new(new_resource.name)
+          after_resource.package_name(new_resource.package_name)
+          after_resource.version(get_current_versions)
+
+          after_resource
+        end
+
         def define_resource_requirements
           requirements.assert(:install, :upgrade, :remove, :purge) do |a|
             a.assertion { !new_resource.source || ::File.exist?(new_resource.source) }
@@ -80,9 +91,15 @@ class Chef
           end
         end
 
+        def magic_version_array
+          package_name_array.each_with_index.map do |pkg, i|
+            magical_version(i).version_with_arch
+          end
+        end
+
         def get_current_versions
           package_name_array.each_with_index.map do |pkg, i|
-            installed_version(i).version_with_arch
+            current_version(i).version_with_arch
           end
         end
 
@@ -127,7 +144,7 @@ class Chef
         alias upgrade_package install_package
 
         def remove_package(names, versions)
-          resolved_names = names.each_with_index.map { |name, i| installed_version(i).to_s unless name.nil? }
+          resolved_names = names.each_with_index.map { |name, i| magical_version(i).to_s unless name.nil? }
           yum(options, "-y", "remove", resolved_names)
           flushcache
         end
@@ -157,10 +174,10 @@ class Chef
         def resolved_package_lock_names(names)
           names.each_with_index.map do |name, i|
             unless name.nil?
-              if installed_version(i).version.nil?
+              if magical_version(i).version.nil?
                 available_version(i).name
               else
-                installed_version(i).name
+                magical_version(i).name
               end
             end
           end
@@ -226,15 +243,25 @@ class Chef
           @available_version[index]
         end
 
+        def magical_version(index)
+          @magical_version ||= []
+          @magical_version[index] ||= if new_resource.source
+                                        python_helper.package_query(:whatinstalled, available_version(index).name, version: safe_version_array[index], arch: safe_arch_array[index], options: options)
+                                      else
+                                        python_helper.package_query(:whatinstalled, package_name_array[index], version: safe_version_array[index], arch: safe_arch_array[index], options: options)
+                                      end
+          @magical_version[index]
+        end
+
         # @return Array<Version>
-        def installed_version(index)
-          @installed_version ||= []
-          @installed_version[index] ||= if new_resource.source
-                                          python_helper.package_query(:whatinstalled, available_version(index).name, arch: safe_arch_array[index], options: options)
-                                        else
-                                          python_helper.package_query(:whatinstalled, package_name_array[index], arch: safe_arch_array[index], options: options)
-                                        end
-          @installed_version[index]
+        def current_version(index)
+          @current_version ||= []
+          @current_version[index] ||= if new_resource.source
+                                        python_helper.package_query(:whatinstalled, available_version(index).name, arch: safe_arch_array[index], options: options)
+                                      else
+                                        python_helper.package_query(:whatinstalled, package_name_array[index], arch: safe_arch_array[index], options: options)
+                                      end
+          @current_version[index]
         end
 
         def flushcache
diff --git a/lib/chef/provider/package/yum/python_helper.rb b/lib/chef/provider/package/yum/python_helper.rb
index db929ea88b..adf950ee88 100644
--- a/lib/chef/provider/package/yum/python_helper.rb
+++ b/lib/chef/provider/package/yum/python_helper.rb
@@ -115,17 +115,71 @@ class Chef
             end
           end
 
+          def is_arch?(arch)
+            # cspell:disable-next
+            arches = %w{alpha alphaev4 alphaev45 alphaev5 alphaev56 alphaev6 alphaev67 alphaev68 alphaev7 alphapca56 amd64 armv5tejl armv5tel armv6l armv7l athlon geode i386 i486 i586 i686 ia32e ia64 noarch ppc ppc64 ppc64iseries ppc64pseries s390 s390x sh3 sh4 sh4a sparc sparc64 sparc64v sparcv8 sparcv9 sparcv9v x86_64}
+            arches.include?(arch)
+          end
+
+          # We have a provides line with an epoch in it and yum cannot parse that, so we
+          # need to deconstruct the args.  This doesn't support splats which is why we
+          # only do it for this particularly narrow use case.
+          #
+          # name-epoch:version
+          # name-epoch:version.arch
+          # name-epoch:version-release
+          # name-epoch:version-release.arch
+          #
+          def deconstruct_args(provides)
+            raise "provides must have an epoch in the version to deconstruct" unless provides =~ /^(\S+)-(\d+):(\S+)/
+
+            name = $1
+            epoch = $2
+            other = $3
+            ret = { "provides" => name, "epoch" => epoch }
+            maybe_arch = other.rpartition(".").last
+            arch = if is_arch?(maybe_arch)
+                     other.delete_suffix!(".#{maybe_arch}")
+                     maybe_arch
+                   end
+            ret.merge!({ "arch" => arch }) if arch
+            (version, _, release) = other.rpartition("-")
+            if version.empty?
+              ret.merge!({ "version" => release }) # yeah, rpartition is just weird
+            else
+              ret.merge!({ "version" => version, "release" => release })
+            end
+          end
+
+          def combine_args(provides, version, arch)
+            provides = provides.dup
+            maybe_arch = provides.rpartition(".").last
+            if is_arch?(maybe_arch)
+              arch = maybe_arch
+              provides.delete_suffix!(".#{arch}")
+            end
+            provides = "#{provides}-#{version}" if version
+            provides = "#{provides}.#{arch}" if arch
+            # yum (on rhel7) can't handle an epoch in provides, but
+            # deconstructing the args can't handle dealing with globs
+            if provides =~ /-\d+:/ && provides !~ /[\*\?]/
+              deconstruct_args(provides)
+            else
+              { "provides" => provides }
+            end
+          end
+
           # @return Array<Version>
           # NB: "options" here is the yum_package options hash and is deliberately not **opts
           def package_query(action, provides, version: nil, arch: nil, options: {})
-            parameters = { "provides" => provides, "version" => version, "arch" => arch }
+            parameters = combine_args(provides, version, arch)
             repo_opts = options_params(options || {})
             parameters.merge!(repo_opts)
             # XXX: for now we close the rpmdb before and after every query with an enablerepo/disablerepo to clean the helpers internal state
             close_rpmdb unless repo_opts.empty?
             query_output = query(action, parameters)
             version = parse_response(query_output.lines.last)
-            Chef::Log.trace "parsed #{version} from python helper"
+            puts "parsed #{version} from python helper"
             close_rpmdb unless repo_opts.empty?
             version
           end
@@ -159,11 +213,11 @@ class Chef
           def query(action, parameters)
             with_helper do
               json = build_query(action, parameters)
-              Chef::Log.trace "sending '#{json}' to python helper"
+              puts "sending '#{json}' to python helper"
               outpipe.puts json
               outpipe.flush
               output = inpipe.readline.chomp
-              Chef::Log.trace "got '#{output}' from python helper"
+              puts "got '#{output}' from python helper"
               output
             end
           end
@@ -175,9 +229,9 @@ class Chef
             end
 
             # Special handling for certain action / param combos
-            if %i{whatinstalled whatavailable}.include?(action)
-              add_version(hash, parameters["version"]) unless parameters["version"].nil?
-            end
+            # if %i{whatinstalled whatavailable}.include?(action)
+            #  add_version(hash, parameters["version"]) unless parameters["version"].nil?
+            # end
 
             FFI_Yajl::Encoder.encode(hash)
           end
diff --git a/spec/functional/resource/yum_package_spec.rb b/spec/functional/resource/yum_package_spec.rb
index d401651f70..1d6c5c8019 100644
--- a/spec/functional/resource/yum_package_spec.rb
+++ b/spec/functional/resource/yum_package_spec.rb
@@ -81,36 +81,40 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
     context "vanilla use case" do
       it "installs if the package is not installed" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "does not install if the package is installed" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
-        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "does not install twice" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "does not install if the prior version package is installed" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
@@ -118,8 +122,9 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
       it "does not install if the i686 package is installed", :intel_64bit do
         skip "FIXME: do nothing, or install the #{pkg_arch} version?"
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$")
       end
@@ -127,77 +132,234 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
       it "does not install if the prior version i686 package is installed", :intel_64bit do
         skip "FIXME: do nothing, or install the #{pkg_arch} version?"
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.i686.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.i686$")
       end
     end
 
+    context "expanded idempotency checks with version variants" do
+      # 0:1.10, 0:1.10-1, 0:1*-1 don't work on yum/el6
+      %w{1.10 1* 1.10-1 1*-1 1.10-* 1*-* 0:1* *:1.10-* *:1*-*}.each do |vstring|
+        it "installs the rpm when #{vstring} is in the package_name" do
+          flush_cache
+          yum_package "chef_rpm-#{vstring}" do
+            options default_options
+            action :install
+          end.should_be_updated
+        end
+
+        it "is idempotent when #{vstring} is in the package_name" do
+          preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          yum_package "chef_rpm-#{vstring}" do
+            options default_options
+            action :install
+          end.should_not_be_updated
+        end
+
+        it "installs the rpm when #{vstring} is in the version property" do
+          flush_cache
+          yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+            options default_options
+            version vstring
+            action :install
+          end.should_be_updated
+        end
+
+        it "is idempotent when #{vstring} is in the version property" do
+          preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+            options default_options
+            version vstring
+            action :install
+          end.should_not_be_updated
+        end
+
+        it "upgrades the rpm when #{vstring} is in the package_name" do
+          flush_cache
+          yum_package "chef_rpm-#{vstring}" do
+            options default_options
+            action :upgrade
+          end.should_be_updated
+        end
+
+        it "is idempotent when #{vstring} is in the package_name" do
+          preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          yum_package "chef_rpm-#{vstring}" do
+            options default_options
+            action :upgrade
+          end.should_not_be_updated
+        end
+
+        it "upgrades the rpm when #{vstring} is in the version property" do
+          flush_cache
+          yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+            options default_options
+            version vstring
+            action :upgrade
+          end.should_be_updated
+        end
+
+        it "is idempotent when #{vstring} is in the version property" do
+          preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+            options default_options
+            version vstring
+            action :upgrade
+          end.should_not_be_updated
+        end
+      end
+
+      # 0:1.2 0:1.2-1 0:1*-1 don't work on yum/el6
+      %w{1.2 1* 1.2-1 1*-1 1.2-* 1*-* 0:1* *:1.2-* *:1*-*}.each do |vstring|
+        it "is idempotent when #{vstring} is in the version property and there is a candidate version" do
+          preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+            options default_options
+            version vstring
+            action :install
+          end.should_not_be_updated
+          expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        end
+      end
+
+      # 0:1.2, 0:1.2-1, 0:1*-1 don't work on yum/el6
+      %w{1.2 1.2-1 1.2-* *:1.2-*}.each do |vstring|
+        it "is idempotent when #{vstring} is in the version property on upgrade and it doesn't match the candidate version" do
+          preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+            options default_options
+            version vstring
+            action :upgrade
+          end.should_not_be_updated
+          expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        end
+      end
+
+      # 0:1.2, 0:1.2-1, 0:1*-1 don't work on yum/el6
+      %w{1* 1*-1 1*-* 0:1* *:1*-*}.each do |vstring|
+        it "upgrades when #{vstring} is in the version property on upgrade and it matches the candidate version" do
+          preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+            options default_options
+            version vstring
+            action :upgrade
+          end.should_be_updated
+          expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+          yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+            options default_options
+            version vstring
+            action :upgrade
+          end.should_not_be_updated
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
     context "with versions or globs in the name" do
       it "works with a version" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1.10") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "works with an older version" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "works with an evra" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-0:1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-0:1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-0:1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "works with version and release" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1.2-1") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2-1" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2-1" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "works with a version glob" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1*") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1*" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1*" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "works with a name glob + version glob" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rp*-1*") do
+        yum_package "chef_rp*-1*" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rp*-1*" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "upgrades when the installed version does not match the version string" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1.10") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "downgrades when the installed version is higher than the package_name version" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1.2") do
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
 
@@ -205,221 +367,349 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
     context "with version property" do
       it "matches the full version" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          version("1.10")
+          version "1.10"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "matches with a glob" do
-        # we are unlikely to ever fix this.  if you've found this comment you should use e.g. "tcpdump-4*" in
-        # the name field rather than trying to use a name of "tcpdump" and a version of "4*".
-        pending "this does not work, is not easily supported by the underlying yum libraries, but does work in the new dnf_package provider"
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          version("1*")
+          version "1*"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1*"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "matches the vr" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          version("1.10-1")
+          version "1.10-1"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "matches the evr" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          version("0:1.10-1")
+          version "0:1.10-1"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "0:1.10-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "matches with a vr glob" do
-        pending "doesn't work on command line either"
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          version("1.10-1*")
+          version "1.10-1*"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10-1*"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "matches with an evr glob" do
-        pending "doesn't work on command line either"
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          version("0:1.10-1*")
+          version "0:1.10-1*"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "0:1.10-1*"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
 
     context "downgrades" do
-      it "downgrades the package when allow_downgrade" do
+      it "downgrades the package when allow_downgrade is true" do
         flush_cache
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          allow_downgrade true
-          version("1.2-1")
+          version "1.2-1"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.2-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "does not downgrade the package when allow_downgrade is false" do
+        flush_cache
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          allow_downgrade false
+          version "1.2-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
     end
 
     context "with arches", :intel_64bit do
       it "installs with 64-bit arch in the name" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "installs with 32-bit arch in the name" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm.i686") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.i686" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.i686" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "installs with 64-bit arch in the property" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          arch((pkg_arch).to_s)
+          arch pkg_arch
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          arch pkg_arch
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "installs with 32-bit arch in the property" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
-          arch("i686")
+          arch "i686"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          arch "i686"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "installs when the 32-bit arch is in the name and the version is in the property" do
+        flush_cache
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.i686" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.i686" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "installs when the 64-bit arch is in the name and the version is in the property" do
+        flush_cache
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
 
     context "with constraints" do
       it "with nothing installed, it installs the latest version" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm >= 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm >= 1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm >= 1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "when it is met, it does nothing" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm >= 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm >= 1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "when it is met, it does nothing" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm >= 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm >= 1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
-      it "with nothing intalled, it installs the latest version" do
+      it "with nothing installed, it installs the latest version" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm > 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "when it is not met by an installed rpm, it upgrades" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm > 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "with an equality constraint, when it is not met by an installed rpm, it upgrades" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm = 1.10") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm = 1.10" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm = 1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "with an equality constraint, when it is met by an installed rpm, it does nothing" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm = 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm = 1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "when it is met by an installed rpm, it does nothing" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm > 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
-      it "when there is no solution to the constraint" do
+      it "when there is no solution to the contraint" do
         flush_cache
         expect {
-          yum_package("chef_rpm > 2.0") do
-            options default_options
-          end
+          yum_package "chef_rpm > 2.0"
         }.to raise_error(Chef::Exceptions::Package, /No candidate version available/)
       end
 
-      it "when there is no solution to the constraint but an rpm is preinstalled" do
+      it "when there is no solution to the contraint but an rpm is preinstalled" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
         expect {
-          yum_package("chef_rpm > 2.0") do
-            options default_options
-          end
+          yum_package "chef_rpm > 2.0"
         }.to raise_error(Chef::Exceptions::Package, /No candidate version available/)
       end
 
       it "with a less than constraint, when nothing is installed, it installs" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm < 1.10") do
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "with a less than constraint, when the install version matches, it does nothing" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm < 1.10") do
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "with a less than constraint, when the install version fails, it should downgrade" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm < 1.10") do
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
 
@@ -427,95 +717,110 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
       it "raises an exception when the package does not exist" do
         flush_cache
         expect {
-          yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/this-file-better-not-exist.rpm") do
-            options default_options
-          end
+          yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/this-file-better-not-exist.rpm"
         }.to raise_error(Chef::Exceptions::Package, /No candidate version available/)
       end
 
       it "does not raise a hard exception in why-run mode when the package does not exist" do
         Chef::Config[:why_run] = true
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/this-file-better-not-exist.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/this-file-better-not-exist.rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end
       end
 
       it "installs the package when using the source argument" do
         flush_cache
         yum_package "something" do
-          package_name "somethingelse"
           source("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          options default_options
+          package_name "somethingelse"
+          name "something"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "something" do
+          source("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          options default_options
+          package_name "somethingelse"
+          name "something"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "installs the package when the name is a path to a file" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
-      it "downgrade on a local file is ignored when allow_downgrade is false" do
+      it "downgrade on a local file with allow_downgrade true works" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
-          allow_downgrade false
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
+          options default_options
           version "1.2-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
+          version "1.2-1"
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
-        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
-      it "downgrade on a local file with allow_downgrade true works" do
+      it "downgrade on a local file with allow_downgrade false does not downgrade" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
-          version "1.2-1"
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
-        end.should_be_updated
-        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+          allow_downgrade false
+          version "1.2-1"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "does not downgrade the package with :install" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "does not upgrade the package with :install" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "is idempotent when the package is already installed" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "is idempotent when the package is already installed and there is a version string" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
-          version "1.2-1"
-          options default_options
-        end.should_not_be_updated
-        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
-      end
-
-      it "is idempotent when the package is already installed and there is a version string with arch" do
-        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
-          version "1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}"
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
+          version "1.2-1"
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
@@ -527,6 +832,7 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
         yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options "--nogpgcheck"
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
@@ -534,28 +840,39 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
       it "works with a local source" do
         FileUtils.rm_f "/etc/yum.repos.d/chef-yum-localtesting.repo"
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options "--nogpgcheck"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
+          options "--nogpgcheck"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
 
     context "multipackage with arches", :intel_64bit do
       it "installs two rpms" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package([ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] ) do
+        yum_package [ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$/)
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$/)
+        yum_package [ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "does nothing if both are installed" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm", "chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686.rpm")
         flush_cache
-        yum_package([ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] ) do
+        yum_package [ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
@@ -563,18 +880,28 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
         yum_package [ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$/)
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$/)
+        yum_package [ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "installs the first rpm if the second is installed" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686.rpm")
         yum_package [ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] do
           options default_options
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$/)
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$/)
+        yum_package [ "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}", "chef_rpm.i686" ] do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       # unlikely to work consistently correct, okay to deprecate the arch-array in favor of the arch in the name
@@ -583,9 +910,15 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         yum_package %w{chef_rpm chef_rpm} do
           options default_options
           arch [pkg_arch, "i686"]
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$/)
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$/)
+        yum_package %w{chef_rpm chef_rpm} do
+          options default_options
+          arch [pkg_arch, "i686"]
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       # unlikely to work consistently correct, okay to deprecate the arch-array in favor of the arch in the name
@@ -594,9 +927,14 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         yum_package %w{chef_rpm chef_rpm} do
           options default_options
           arch [pkg_arch, "i686"]
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$/)
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$/)
+        yum_package %w{chef_rpm chef_rpm} do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       # unlikely to work consistently correct, okay to deprecate the arch-array in favor of the arch in the name
@@ -605,9 +943,14 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         yum_package %w{chef_rpm chef_rpm} do
           options default_options
           arch [pkg_arch, "i686"]
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$/)
         expect_matching_installed_version(/^chef_rpm-1.10-1.i686$/)
+        yum_package %w{chef_rpm chef_rpm} do
+          options default_options
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       # unlikely to work consistently correct, okay to deprecate the arch-array in favor of the arch in the name
@@ -616,6 +959,7 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         yum_package %w{chef_rpm chef_rpm} do
           options default_options
           arch [pkg_arch, "i686"]
+          action :install
         end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
@@ -626,6 +970,7 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         expect {
           yum_package "chef_rpm" do
             options "--nogpgcheck --disablerepo=chef-yum-localtesting"
+            action :install
           end
         }.to raise_error(Chef::Exceptions::Package, /No candidate version available/)
       end
@@ -633,9 +978,14 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
       it "should work with disablerepo first" do
         flush_cache
         yum_package "chef_rpm" do
-          options "--nogpgcheck --disablerepo=* --enablerepo=chef-yum-localtesting"
+          options ["--nogpgcheck", "--disablerepo=*", "--enablerepo=chef-yum-localtesting"]
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options ["--nogpgcheck", "--disablerepo=*", "--enablerepo=chef-yum-localtesting"]
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "should work to enable a disabled repo" do
@@ -644,13 +994,19 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         expect {
           yum_package "chef_rpm" do
             options "--nogpgcheck"
+            action :install
           end
         }.to raise_error(Chef::Exceptions::Package, /No candidate version available/)
         flush_cache
         yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options "--nogpgcheck --enablerepo=chef-yum-localtesting"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options "--nogpgcheck --enablerepo=chef-yum-localtesting"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "when an idempotent install action is run, does not leave repos disabled" do
@@ -667,58 +1023,107 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
         # now we're still using the same cache in the yum_helper.py cache and we test to see if the
         # repo that we temporarily disabled is enabled on this pass.
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}" do
           options "--nogpgcheck"
+          action :install
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}" do
+          options "--nogpgcheck"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
   end
 
   describe ":upgrade" do
+    context "downgrades" do
+      it "just work with DNF" do
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.2"
+          action :install
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect(shell_out("rpm -q chef_rpm").stdout.chomp).to match("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.2"
+          action :install
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+    end
 
     context "with source arguments" do
       it "installs the package when using the source argument" do
         flush_cache
         yum_package "something" do
+          options default_options
           package_name "somethingelse"
           source("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "something" do
+          options default_options
+          package_name "somethingelse"
+          source("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "installs the package when the name is a path to a file" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "downgrades the package when allow_downgrade is true" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "does not downgrade the package when allow_downgrade is false" do
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          allow_downgrade false
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
       end
 
       it "upgrades the package" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "is idempotent when the package is already installed" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_not_be_updated
@@ -730,7 +1135,7 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
       it "works when a package is installed" do
         FileUtils.rm_f "/etc/yum.repos.d/chef-yum-localtesting.repo"
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options "--nogpgcheck"
           action :upgrade
         end.should_not_be_updated
@@ -740,74 +1145,186 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
       it "works with a local source" do
         FileUtils.rm_f "/etc/yum.repos.d/chef-yum-localtesting.repo"
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm") do
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
           options "--nogpgcheck"
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "#{CHEF_SPEC_ASSETS}/yumrepo/chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm" do
+          options "--nogpgcheck"
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
 
     context "version pinning" do
-      it "with an equality pin in the name it upgrades a prior package" do
+      it "with a full version pin it installs a later package" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1.10") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          version "1.10-1"
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10-1"
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
-      it "with a prco equality pin in the name it upgrades a prior package" do
+      it "with a full version pin in the name it downgrades the package" do
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.2-1"
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.2-1"
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "with a partial (no release) version pin it installs a later package" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm == 1.10") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          version "1.10"
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version "1.10"
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
-      it "with an equality pin in the name it downgrades a later package" do
+      it "with a partial (no release) version pin in the name it downgrades the package" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm-1.2") do
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
           options default_options
+          version("1.2")
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          version("1.2")
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "with a full version pin it installs a later package" do
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10-1" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10-1" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "with a full version pin in the name it downgrades the package" do
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2-1" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2-1" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "with a partial (no release) version pin it installs a later package" do
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "with a partial (no release) version pin in the name it downgrades the package" do
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm-1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
+      end
+
+      it "with a prco equality pin in the name it upgrades a prior package" do
+        preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm = 1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_be_updated
+        expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm = 1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "with a prco equality pin in the name it downgrades a later package" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm == 1.2") do
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "chef_rpm = 1.2" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm = 1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "with a > pin in the name and no rpm installed it installs" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm > 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "with a < pin in the name and no rpm installed it installs" do
         flush_cache
-        yum_package("chef_rpm < 1.10") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "with a > pin in the name and matching rpm installed it does nothing" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm > 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_not_be_updated
@@ -816,7 +1333,7 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
 
       it "with a < pin in the name and no rpm installed it installs" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm < 1.10") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_not_be_updated
@@ -825,21 +1342,28 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
 
       it "with a > pin in the name and non-matching rpm installed it upgrades" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm > 1.2") do
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm > 1.2" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "with a < pin in the name and non-matching rpm installed it downgrades" do
         preinstall("chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}.rpm")
-        yum_package("chef_rpm < 1.10") do
-          allow_downgrade true
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
           options default_options
           action :upgrade
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.2-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm < 1.10" do
+          options default_options
+          action :upgrade
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
   end
@@ -885,6 +1409,10 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
           action :remove
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^package chef_rpm is not installed$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          action :remove
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "removes the package if the i686 package is installed", :intel_64bit do
@@ -895,6 +1423,10 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
           action :remove
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^package chef_rpm is not installed$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          action :remove
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "removes the package if the prior version i686 package is installed", :intel_64bit do
@@ -905,6 +1437,10 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
           action :remove
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^package chef_rpm is not installed$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options default_options
+          action :remove
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
 
@@ -925,6 +1461,10 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
           action :remove
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^package chef_rpm is not installed$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}" do
+          options default_options
+          action :remove
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "removes the package if the prior version package is installed" do
@@ -934,6 +1474,10 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
           action :remove
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^package chef_rpm is not installed$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.#{pkg_arch}" do
+          options default_options
+          action :remove
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
 
       it "does nothing if the i686 package is installed" do
@@ -963,6 +1507,10 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
           action :remove
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^chef_rpm-1.10-1.#{pkg_arch}$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm.i686" do
+          options default_options
+          action :remove
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
 
@@ -975,6 +1523,10 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
           action :remove
         end.should_be_updated
         expect_matching_installed_version("^package chef_rpm is not installed$")
+        yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+          options "--nogpgcheck"
+          action :remove
+        end.should_not_be_updated
       end
     end
   end
@@ -990,17 +1542,21 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
 
     it "locks an rpm" do
       flush_cache
-      yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+      yum_package "chef_rpm" do
         options default_options
         action :lock
       end.should_be_updated
       expect(shell_out("yum versionlock list").stdout.chomp).to match("^0:chef_rpm-")
+      yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+        options default_options
+        action :lock
+      end.should_not_be_updated
     end
 
     it "does not lock if its already locked" do
       flush_cache
       shell_out!("yum versionlock add chef_rpm")
-      yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+      yum_package "chef_rpm" do
         options default_options
         action :lock
       end.should_not_be_updated
@@ -1010,16 +1566,20 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
     it "unlocks an rpm" do
       flush_cache
       shell_out!("yum versionlock add chef_rpm")
-      yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+      yum_package "chef_rpm" do
         options default_options
         action :unlock
       end.should_be_updated
       expect(shell_out("yum versionlock list").stdout.chomp).not_to match("^0:chef_rpm-")
+      yum_package "chef_rpm" do
+        options default_options
+        action :unlock
+      end.should_not_be_updated
     end
 
     it "does not unlock an already locked rpm" do
       flush_cache
-      yum_package("chef_rpm") do
+      yum_package "chef_rpm" do
         options default_options
         action :unlock
       end.should_not_be_updated
@@ -1028,21 +1588,29 @@ describe Chef::Resource::YumPackage, :requires_root, external: exclude_test do
 
     it "check that we can lock based on provides" do
       flush_cache
-      yum_package("chef_rpm_provides") do
+      yum_package "chef_rpm_provides" do
         options default_options
         action :lock
       end.should_be_updated
       expect(shell_out("yum versionlock list").stdout.chomp).to match("^0:chef_rpm-")
+      yum_package "chef_rpm_provides" do
+        options default_options
+        action :lock
+      end.should_not_be_updated
     end
 
     it "check that we can unlock based on provides" do
       flush_cache
       shell_out!("yum versionlock add chef_rpm")
-      yum_package("chef_rpm_provides") do
+      yum_package "chef_rpm_provides" do
         options default_options
         action :unlock
       end.should_be_updated
       expect(shell_out("yum versionlock list").stdout.chomp).not_to match("^0:chef_rpm-")
+      yum_package "chef_rpm_provides" do
+        options default_options
+        action :unlock
+      end.should_not_be_updated
     end
   end
 end